Fair Deal Home Buyers

• Email
  This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
• Property Address*
  Street Address
• Phone
• Email*

• [email protected]

• 414.409.8251

Menu

Sell Your House

We Buy Houses in Milwaukee, WI

Sell your house fast with Fair Deal Home Buyers and get a fair all-cash offer within 24 hours.

Mequon-Based, Milwaukee-Rooted

13+

Years Serving Greater Milwaukee

4.8

109 Verified Google Reviews

1000+

Homes Purchased Across Wisconsin

Cash Home Buyers in Milwaukee – And We Actually Know the Market

There’s no shortage of companies claiming to buy houses in Milwaukee. Most are out-of-state operators or one-person wholesalers working off a script. We’re different, and the difference is something you’ll feel from the first conversation.

Fair Deal Home Buyers is based in Greater Milwaukee. We’ve bought homes in Bay View, the North Shore, Wauwatosa, Waukesha, and dozens of communities across Milwaukee County. We understand local property values, the condition of Wisconsin’s aging housing stock, and the real-world situations that push homeowners to sell – fast.

Here’s What Sets Us Apart

Selling a house fast doesn’t have to mean accepting a lowball offer. We’ve built our reputation on making fair cash offers that reflect your property’s actual value – then backing it up with a process that closes on your timeline.

• No repairs, cleaning, or showings
• Close in as little as 3 days
• We handle all paperwork and closing costs
• Support relocating, clearing out, or finding your next place

WATCH‎ THIS

● A Real Team, Not a One-Man Operation
You’ll work with dedicated transaction coordinators, a licensed real estate brokerage, and closing specialists – all under one roof. When we say we’ll close, we do. Even when complications come up.

● 13+ Years of Milwaukee-Area Deals
We’ve navigated probate sales, foreclosures, divorce settlements, and inherited properties across Milwaukee County. That experience means fewer surprises and faster closings for you.

● Flexible Beyond the Cash Offer
Need more time to move? Want to explore creative financing? Prefer to list with a licensed agent? We offer all three paths – and we’ll tell you which one makes the most financial sense for your situation, even if it’s not a direct sale to us.

● Zero Fees, Zero Guesswork
No agent commissions. No closing costs. No repair requests. What we offer is what you walk away with.

How to Sell Your House Fast in Milwaukee – 3 Steps, No Surprises

We designed our process around one idea: your time matters. Here’s how it works from first contact to cash in hand.

1

Tell Us About Your Property

Fill out the short form or give us a call. We’ll ask a few basic questions about the property – condition, timeline, situation. No judgment, no pressure.

2

Receive Your Fair Cash Offer Within 24 Hours

We’ll research your property and come back with a written cash offer. Our offers are based on real Milwaukee market data, not automated algorithms.

3

Step 3 – Close on Your Schedule

Pick a closing date that works for you – as fast as 3 days or as far out as you need. We coordinate with the title company, handle all paperwork, and cover closing costs. You show up and sign.

We Buy Milwaukee Houses in Any Condition – Any Situation

Life doesn’t wait for a perfect market. We buy houses from Milwaukee homeowners dealing with:

✅ Inherited properties and probate

✅ Foreclosure or pre-foreclosure

✅ Divorce

✅ Delinquent taxes or liens

✅ Problem tenants or rentals you’re done managing

✅ Major repairs you can’t afford or don’t want to deal with

✅ Relocation on a tight timeline

✅ Downsizing after a life change

If you’re not sure whether your situation qualifies, call us. In 13+ years we’ve seen it all – and if we can’t help you directly, we’ll point you toward someone who can.

Milwaukee’s Cash Home Buyers – Rooted in Greater Milwaukee for 13+ Years

Our office is in Mequon, 15 minutes north of downtown Milwaukee on Lake Michigan. We’re not a national brand with a local phone number – we’re your neighbors, and we’ve been buying Milwaukee-area homes long enough to see neighborhoods transform, markets shift, and what it really takes to serve a homeowner fairly.

We’ve purchased homes throughout Milwaukee County – from established neighborhoods on the North Shore to working-class communities on the South Side. We know what a house in Bay View is worth versus one in West Allis. We understand Milwaukee’s housing stock – much of it built before 1960 – and we price our offers accordingly.

When you work with us, you’re working with people who have a stake in this community. We renovate the homes we buy and put them back into the Milwaukee market. That’s not a marketing line – it’s what we’ve been doing for over a decade.

Find Out How We Make Selling Easy!

Hi, I’m Scarlette ↴

Ready to Sell Your House Fast in Milwaukee? Get Your Cash Offer Today.

You’ve got nothing to lose and nothing to prepare. No cleaning, no repairs, no open houses. Just fill out the form below and our team will be in touch within hours – not days.

We buy houses in Milwaukee, Waukesha, Racine, Kenosha, Madison, Green Bay, and communities across Wisconsin. Whatever your situation, we’re ready to help.

Hi, I’m Ina ↴

Experience the Benefits of Selling Your Home to Fair Deal Home Buyers

With a traditional home sale, you’ll often face 6% agent commissions, cleaning, repairs, and a months-long waiting game. However, we do things differently.

Zero Fees

Unlike traditional real estate sales, there are no realtor commissions, listing costs, or closing fees when you sell to Fair Deal Home Buyers. We cover 100% of the transaction costs.

Sell As-Is

Forget repairs, cleaning, or staging. We buy Wisconsin houses exactly as they are. Whether the property has cosmetic issues, structural problems, or is filled with belongings, you can walk away without lifting a finger.

Fast Closings

Unlike traditional real estate sales, there are no realtor commissions, listing costs, or closing fees when you sell to Fair Deal Home Buyers. We cover 100% of the transaction costs.

Guaranteed Reliability

With us, you don’t have to worry about buyers backing out or funding falling through. We buy houses in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, with cash, and our experienced team ensures a smooth, professional experience from start to finish.

Meet the Team Behind the Offer

See What Our Clients Are Saying About Us

We’ve built our reputation on transparency and follow-through with homeowners across Wisconsin. These client testimonials show how we deliver on that promise:

“I didn’t even have to move my feet. It was perfect and fast!”

“It’s been easy to work with you guys, you’ve been super helpful.”

“It just seemed pretty fair and straight up.”

“Awesome communication skills”

They did a great job, awesome communication skills, kept their promises all the way through the deal. Great company to work with.

Michael G.

“Smooth transactions and professional”

Great people to work with! Smooth and easy transactions and everyone is very nice and professional!

Sharon Lee

“Great to deal with, highly recommend”

I worked with Fair Deal Home Buyers on a property in Wisconsin Rapids and they were great to deal with. Excellent communication – Highly recommended!

Travis Haines

See More Testimonials

4.8
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Based on 109 Google reviews

See all Google Reviews

         Posted on         Victor Rohrig  May 11, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Fair Deal Home Buyers were excellent to work with in selling our home from start to finish. They were upfront and honest through out the process. I highly recommend them.         Posted on         Jeff Grochowski  May 10, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I had really good experience with Fair Deal Home Buyers during a  challenging time in my life. After losing my job due to a kidney condition and facing imminent foreclosure, I reached out to Fair Deal Home Buyers. They were there when I needed it most.
From the start, they went above and beyond to assist me. They arranged for a moving company to transport all my belongings to a storage unit and even helped with the packing. Despite my low qualification, they found me a rental property to move into. They also managed to secure a storage unit for the items I couldn't take along.
During the transition, they arranged for me to stay in a hotel until my new apartment was ready, ensuring I had a smooth and stress-free move. I closed the sale with them before moving, and they took care of everything I had to leave behind.
Thanks to Fair Deal Home Buyers, I could focus on my health without the burden of my previous housing situation. Their compassionate and thorough support during this critical time allowed me to move forward with peace of mind         Posted on         David Reyrey  May 10, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Everything went smoothly and everyone made time for our work schedule as well for our dogs scheduled I would recommend fair deal home buyers LLC to all who seek to sell there home thanks to all who helped         Posted on         Thomas Robarge  May 1, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I recently had the pleasure of working with Ina at Fair Deal Home Buyers, and I must say, it was an outstanding experience from start to finish. Ina's professionalism, expertise, and genuine care for her clients truly set her apart. I wholeheartedly recommend her services to anyone in need of assistance. Thank you, Ina, for your outstanding help!         Posted on         Elle Dunn  April 6, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. My experience with Fair Deal Home Buyers was extremely professional and highly ethical. The entire team communicated daily with any updated information needed to streamline my selling process. I recommend Fair Deal Home Buyers for those in search of a highly ethical, professional, and team oriented real estate company.         Posted on         Lisa bowen  March 1, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. If you are looking to sell your house, Fair Deal Home Buyers LLC are very professional and they won’t try to low ball you on the value of your property. Very respectfull and helpful when you have questions or concerns. Beza was my main contact and she was wonderful and prompt getting back to me with the questions I had and processing the paperwork. If you are looking to sell your house, give them a call, you won’t be disappointed.         Posted on         Dale Fleenor  February 1, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Polite courteous very professional staff everybody I work with there understood my needs and worked in cooperated to make sure that they happened . I would highly recommend them to anybody.         Posted on         The Shop FM Network  January 31, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great group of people that take their time and compassion with each client.         Posted on         Maria Barr  January 24, 2024   Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I was so grateful to find farro deal to sell my home to and it was a great experience with them.       Load more

We Buy Houses in Milwaukee County and Beyond

Jefferson

Ashland

Racine

Kenosha

Waukesha

Madison

Green Bay

Wauwatosa

More Locations →

Frequently Asked Questions

We can close in as little as 3 business days once you accept our offer – faster than almost any other option available to Milwaukee homeowners. That said, we close on your timeline, not ours. If you need 30, 45, or 60 days to get organized, that’s completely fine. We’ll lock in your offer and schedule the closing whenever you’re ready.

We don’t lowball. Our offers are based on real Milwaukee market data and your property’s actual condition. We’ll walk you through how we arrived at our number – and if it doesn’t work for you, there’s zero obligation to accept. Over 1,000 homeowners have worked with us because they found our offers fair and our process transparent.

No. We buy Milwaukee houses exactly as they are – roof damage, foundation issues, outdated systems, full of belongings, whatever the condition. You don’t need to fix anything, clean anything, or remove anything you don’t want. We handle all of that after closing.

None. When you sell to Fair Deal Home Buyers, you pay zero agent commissions, zero closing costs, and zero hidden fees. The offer we make is what you receive at closing. We cover all transaction costs on our end.

A traditional listing in Milwaukee can take 30–90 days (or longer), requires repairs and staging, involves agent commissions of around 5–6%, and comes with the risk of deals falling through due to financing. When you sell to us, you get a guaranteed cash offer, close in days, pay zero fees, and skip all of that uncertainty. The tradeoff is that our offer may be below full retail market value – but for many homeowners, the savings in time, stress, and costs more than make up the difference.

We buy houses throughout all of Milwaukee County and surrounding areas – including Bay View, Wauwatosa, West Allis, the North Shore (Whitefish Bay, Shorewood, Fox Point), Waukesha, Racine, Kenosha, and communities across Wisconsin. If you’re not sure whether your property falls within our service area, call us – the answer is almost always yes.

Tenants are not a problem. We regularly buy occupied rental properties in Milwaukee, including situations with difficult tenants, month-to-month leases, or non-paying occupants. We handle the tenant transition after closing – you don’t have to deal with that process.

This is one of the most common situations we work with. We have experience buying inherited properties and estate homes throughout Milwaukee County. We can work directly with estate attorneys, heirs, and personal representatives to simplify the process. If the property is in active probate, we can discuss timing and help coordinate with your attorney.

Yes. Outstanding property taxes, tax liens, and most other encumbrances can typically be resolved at closing – often paid directly from the sale proceeds. This is something we handle regularly and can discuss with you upfront so there are no surprises.

Fair question. The Milwaukee market has no shortage of companies making cash offers. Here’s what separates us: we’ve been operating in Greater Milwaukee for 13+ years, we have a full team behind every transaction (not a single wholesaler), we’re a licensed Wisconsin real estate brokerage, and we have over 100 verified Google reviews from real sellers. We also offer options beyond a straight cash sale – including creative financing and brokerage listings – so we’re focused on what’s actually best for your situation, not just closing a deal.

The process is simple and straightforward. First, you contact us with your property address and basic details about your situation. We’ll schedule a quick walkthrough of the home — usually within 24 hours. After the visit, we prepare a no-obligation cash offer based on the condition of the property, comparable sales in your Milwaukee neighborhood, and our repair estimates. If you accept, we open escrow, handle all the paperwork, and close at a local title company on your timeline — often in as little as 3 to 7 business days. There are no fees, no commissions, and no surprises.

Yes, in many cases we can. If you owe more on your mortgage than the home is currently worth — a situation called being “underwater” or having negative equity — we may be able to work with your lender on a short sale. In a short sale, the lender agrees to accept less than the full amount owed in order to avoid a lengthy and costly foreclosure. We have experience navigating short sales in Wisconsin and can guide you through the process. Contact us to discuss your specific situation and we’ll let you know what options are available to you.

Cash buyers like Fair Deal Home Buyers use a formula based on the After Repair Value (ARV) of your home — what it would sell for on the open market after all repairs and updates are completed. From that number, we subtract the estimated cost of repairs, our holding costs, and a margin that allows us to stay in business. The result is our cash offer. We’re transparent about this process. We’re not trying to steal your home — we’re providing a service: speed, certainty, and convenience, in exchange for a discount on price. Many sellers find that when they factor in agent commissions, closing costs, months of carrying costs, and repair expenses, our net offer is comparable to or better than a traditional listing.

A cash home buyer like Fair Deal Home Buyers purchases your property directly using our own funds. We close the transaction ourselves and take title to the property. A real estate wholesaler, on the other hand, puts your home under contract and then sells that contract to a third-party investor — often without your knowledge. Wholesalers typically don’t have the funds to close themselves and may back out if they can’t find a buyer. At Fair Deal Home Buyers, we are the buyer. We are also a licensed Wisconsin real estate brokerage, which means we operate under strict legal and ethical standards. You deal directly with us from start to finish.

Closing on a cash sale is much simpler than a traditional financed transaction. We typically close at a local title company in Milwaukee or the surrounding area. You’ll sign the deed and a few other standard documents transferring ownership. The title company will pay off any existing mortgage, liens, or back taxes from the proceeds, and you’ll receive the remaining balance — your net proceeds — either by check or wire transfer on the same day. The entire closing appointment usually takes less than an hour. You don’t need to bring an attorney, though you’re welcome to have one present if you prefer.

Yes. Selling a home during a divorce is one of the most common situations we encounter. A fast cash sale can simplify the division of assets, eliminate ongoing carrying costs like mortgage payments and utilities, and allow both parties to move forward more quickly. Wisconsin is a community property state, which means both spouses typically need to agree to and sign off on the sale. We work with both parties — and their respective attorneys if needed — to ensure the transaction is handled properly and fairly. If you’re going through a divorce and need to sell your Milwaukee home quickly, we’re here to help.

Yes. Tax liens, code violations, and deferred maintenance are among the most common issues we see on the properties we purchase. Milwaukee has strict code enforcement, and many homeowners find themselves overwhelmed by the cost of bringing a property into compliance. We buy houses in as-is condition, which means we take on those issues after closing. Outstanding tax liens and code violation fines are typically paid off at closing from the sale proceeds, so you don’t have to come out of pocket. We handle all of the details so you can move on without the burden.

Yes. Fair Deal Home Buyers operates under Fair Deal Realty, a licensed Wisconsin real estate brokerage. This means we are held to the professional and ethical standards required by the Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services (DSPS). Unlike unlicensed wholesalers or out-of-state investors, we are accountable to the state and to our clients. Our license number and brokerage information are available upon request. We believe transparency and professionalism are what set us apart in the Milwaukee market.

Once you accept our offer, we move quickly. We’ll send you a purchase agreement to sign — this can be done electronically or in person, whichever you prefer. We then open escrow with a local title company, who will conduct a title search to ensure there are no unexpected liens or issues. You’ll choose your closing date, and we’ll coordinate everything from there. You don’t need to make any repairs, clean the house, or do anything special before closing. On closing day, you sign the paperwork, and the funds are transferred to you. The entire process from accepted offer to closing typically takes 7 to 14 days, though we can move faster or slower depending on your needs.

Absolutely. Relocation is one of the most time-sensitive situations a homeowner can face, whether it’s a new job, a military deployment, a family emergency, or simply a desire for a fresh start. We specialize in fast closings — often within 7 to 14 days — and we can work around your schedule. We can also handle the closing remotely if you’ve already moved, using a power of attorney or remote notary services. You don’t need to be present in Milwaukee to sell your house to us. If you need to move quickly and don’t have time for the traditional listing process, call us and we’ll make it happen.